🇧🇬 БГ
Cover of The Citadel, A. J. Cronin
Review Classics · 3 min read

The Citadel

A. J. Cronin

When Idealism Collides With the Price of Success

★★★★★ 4/5 Booklovers
Save to library

The Citadel by A. J. Cronin is beautifully written and gripping from its very first page. It begins as the story of an idealist fighting against the system and gradually becomes a novel about how that same idealist can be consumed by it.

Andrew Manson is an idealistic young doctor who challenges outdated but firmly established medical practices and begins his career at the very bottom, with little prospect of advancement. With impressive speed, Manson manages to “earn” enemies among colleagues who are incompetent yet highly focused on profit. Over time, however, his skill allows him to overcome his patients’ skepticism.

He also finds a few like-minded people, but above all he relies on the unwavering support of his wife, Christine – whom, in my opinion, he repeatedly and undeservedly neglects. I understand Cronin’s intention to turn his protagonist into something of a champion of progress, but I cannot fully embrace Andrew as an entirely positive character.

It is also important to note that the novel is semi-autobiographical. Cronin was himself a physician, and through The Citadel he sets out his ideas about how the medical system could be better organized, while boldly challenging many of the established traditions and ethical conventions of the profession.

The pacing is uneven. The beginning is promising, the middle section becomes more scattered, and the final third picks up considerably once Andrew moves to London and enters the social circles of wealthy and influential patients. It is there that he faces his most serious ethical dilemmas. The doctor who initially seemed so deeply committed to the wellbeing of his patients gradually appears to be corrupted by a society driven by money and power.

An internal conflict emerges between professional success and the ethical ideals associated with the respected medical profession –  questions that remain relevant today, regardless of geography. And inevitably, those professional pressures begin to spill into the protagonist’s personal and family life as well.

Despite the somewhat slower development of parts of the story, reading the novel was a genuine pleasure.

BOOKLOVERS Rating: 4.5/5

Almost nine decades after its publication, The Citadel remains surprisingly relevant. The conflict between professional ethics, scientific progress, money, and personal ambition certainly does not belong only to the medicine of the 1930s.

Join the community

Your library starts here

Every book leaves a mark.
Create your profile and turn what you read into your personal library.

Sign up for free

Follow us on social media:

What did you think of the book?

No comments yet. Be the first.

Have you read the book?

Rate it and share your thoughts with the Booklovers community.

Readers’ rating
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
No ratings yet